Our economic realities could be driving humankind to extinction

population 300pix

Study suggests some human ethnicities could die out in as little as 700 years

By Patrick Vaillancourt, Contributor

There is no more fundamental a decision one could ever face than the question of whether or not to have a child. Children can bring couples and families closer together, bring joy and meaning into one’s life, and allow parents to leave an earthly legacy long after they are gone. Bringing a child into the world is one way parents secure a type of immortality.

At least, this was how people thought about the question of children decades before we came along.

Nowadays, the discussion a couple has with respect to having children is largely centred around economic issues rather than the traditional notions of family unity and legacy. The reality of our generation is that it’s becoming more costly to live, and children are not very cost-effective.

It used to be that parents wanted to bring their children into a world that would surpass their own lifestyle. As children brought the family closer together, parents poured every financial resource they could into ensuring their children were properly educated—in turn, and although an unspoken social contract, children with means would care for aging parents when the time came for them to do so. Children used to be an investment that paid in dividends for parents, and parents had a stake in making sure that their children were as successful as they could be.

The economic realities of our generation, however, make such attitudes to having children appear old-fashioned. Gone are the higher ideals and the benefits of having children, superseded by the economic burdens of raising them and giving them a reasonable opportunity to be successful in a world that has become more demanding of us mentally. To add to these issues, government welfare and retirement programs, such as pension plans and retirement facilities, have allowed traditional attitudes of caring for the elderly to disappear.

The economic realities of our times are such that there is no real incentive to have children. Statistics gathered by governments all over the world show that this trend is real: people are getting married much later than they used to, and having children later and in reduced numbers. This leads us to the new, more significant problem of population management.

Many countries in the world, including Canada, are at a point where the population is unable to replace itself naturally through the birth of new children. This is what’s known as a nation’s fertility rate—the average number of children born throughout a woman’s lifetime. Canada’s fertility rate has been steady at around 1.6 children per woman, and although that rate is still below the replacement rate (usually about 2.1 for developed countries), Canada’s population continues to grow steadily, thanks largely to our nation’s long-held tradition of open immigration. Immigration accounted for two-thirds of Canada’s population growth from July 2012 to July 2013.

Other countries, however, are facing a real crisis which could have catastrophic economic ramifications in the future. In some cases throughout East Asia, there is even talk of a “doomsday scenario” where entire ethnicities may even go extinct if something is not done to encourage an increase in fertility.

A study recently released by the Korean National Assembly Research Service suggests that some Asian ethnicities could become extinct in as little as 700 years. The study takes a look at the fertility rates of countries across East Asia and singles out South Korea, Japan, Taiwan, and Thailand as countries that need to take action to prevent a “doomsday scenario.”

Taiwan, for example, with a fertility rate that has dipped below one child per woman in recent years, will see its population begin to decline in 2022—years earlier than expected.

Calculations made in the report reveal that South Korea, with a fertility rate of 1.19, could see its population decline from 50-million to 40-million in the next half-century. Assuming the status quo remains in the next century, Korea could see its population drop to as low as 10-million by 2136—an 80 per cent drop—while ethnic South Koreans could be extinct by 2750.

In Japan, the situation is critical as there have been a number of years since 2005 when the total deaths have exceeded the total number of births. Out of a population of over 127-million, the total number of births in Japan in 2013 was slightly over one-million, while deaths in Japan in 2013 reached a post-war high, at over 1.2-million. The Korean study calculates that, assuming Japan does not take remedial action, the last Japanese person will die around the year 3011.

Hiroshi Yoshida, a professor at Japan’s Tohoku University who specializes in demographics and the economic realities of ageing populations, suggests that women’s equality movements have pushed more women into the workforce in countries that still have traditional beliefs about women and motherhood.

“These societies have reached the same level as Europe and North America in many aspects, but when it comes to balancing careers and raising children, then East Asia is very immature,” said Yoshida in an interview last week with the South China Morning Post.

The answers to reversing the path to extinction is two-fold: make it more financially bearable to bear children, and open the doors to these countries to an influx of immigrants who wish to call these countries home.

In France, for example, there is a certain honour placed on the notion of motherhood. One reluctant French mother, Corinne Maier, wrote a book discouraging people from having children and characterized France as going through a phase of “baby mania.” One Globe and Mail journalist described France as being “a place where people follow the fertility rate in the same way Americans follow the Dow Jones Industrial Average.”

France is among the leading European countries with a fertility rate hovering around the two children per woman range. It does this by offering generous benefits to women: paid maternity leaves, generous tax benefits and subsidies of $1,000 (Euros) per month for every child they have after their second. Though raising children is a terribly costly enterprise, France reduces the burden on families, allowing them to reproduce at rates which will not negatively affect the demographics or population levels of the country.

Immigration, on the other hand, which has been the model in Canada since Confederation, is not viewed in as high regard in other countries. Celebrations behind France’s high fertility rate came with a knowledge that immigration could be restricted there, where there have been racist tensions in recent years. Germany, like Canada, relies on immigration to keep its population growing, and that population growth has powered the German and European economies for decades.

While many will no doubt be skeptical that a country could ever reach that “doomsday scenario” of extinction, sudden and dramatic reductions in population levels in a country would wreak havoc on a country’s ability to provide services to its people. A growing population means more tax revenues for governments and an ability to keep those taxes low to attract immigrants and business—whereas declining populations mean higher tax burdens placed on fewer and fewer people, often by governments who are forced into cutting services to balance their budgets.

Surely, there can be no greater human interest story than that of backtracking humanity’s path to extinction. Barring a catastrophic cosmic event and assuming global warming doesn’t kill us first, governments will be compelled into looking into the issue of declining populations.


Fertility rate refers to the number of children, on average, that women in a geographical/geopolitical area will have throughout their lifetime.

Replacement rate refers to the number of children, on average, that women in a geographical/geopolitical area would need for the population-level to remain stable (i.e. zero growth).

The replacement rate varies from country to country based on the mortality rate of a country’s population. For example, the replacement rate in Canada is stable at 2.1 children per woman, and that rate is standard throughout much of the developed world. Think of it as a woman having two children, to replace herself and her husband/partner for the next generation.

However, in less-developed countries with high mortality rates (Africa, for example) replacement rates are higher. This is because infant mortality rates among girls tend to be high, so adult women need to produce more children to replace those who could not be born due to mortality rates amongst women of non-child-bearing age. Replacement rates in Africa are higher, ranging from 2.5 to 3.3, according to a 2003 study entitled The Surprising Global Variation in Replacement Fertility.

The Other Press

The Other Press, Douglas College's student newspaper since 1976. Articles, insight and updates from the New West and Coquitlam campuses.

More Posts - Website

2,629 comments on “Our economic realities could be driving humankind to extinction
  1. Pingback: Our economic realities could be driving humankind to extinction – Patrick Vaillancourt

  2. This is very interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger.
    I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your magnificent post.
    Also, I have shared your website in my social networks!

  3. In general, the top techniques involve getting beyond yourself and becoming the woman to talk about her interests.
    Their desires can be for an online relationship of that nature or
    they’re able to arrange through boards a place where they can meet in person. And thanks
    to Disney these fantasies were imbedded a little more forward
    than her genetic wiring ever intended.

  4. Ich genieße, was euch Regel. Diee Art der Deckung!
    Halten Sie siuch die hervorragende ausgezeichneten funktioniert Jungs Ich
    hasbe Hinzugefügt euch zzu medine persönliche Blogroll.

  5. Our latest addition to the limousine fleet is the 7 passenger Cadillac
    Escalade. Be smart and savvy when negotiating the interest rate for new cars and don’t just sign on the bottom line.
    Access Free Online Maps via Wi – Fi or 3G network, such as
    Google Map.

  6. Unquestionably believe that which you said.
    Your favorite reason seemed to be on the internet the simplest thing to be aware of.
    I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that
    they plainly do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the
    top and also defined out the whole thing without having side-effects , people can take a signal.
    Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

  7. Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so much about this,
    like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you can do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but instead of that, this is wonderful blog.
    An excellent read. I will definitely be back.

  8. Woah! Ich bin wirklich Graben die Vorlage / Thema diesees Website.
    Es ist einfach, aber effektiv. Eine Menge Zeit, es ist sehhr schwer, schwierig zu
    bekommen, dass “perfekten Balance” zwischen Usability undd Optik.

    Ich muss sagen, dass Sie haben, Sie haben eine ausgezeichneten Arbeit mitt diesem.
    Auch, die Bllog Lasteen extrem Schnell für mich auf Internet Explorer.
    Ausgezeichnete Blog

  9. Só possui de falar para seu telemóvel e ele responde imediatamente num dos 42 idiomas disponíveis.

    é mestre em pulos, proponho que, para celebrar nosso contrato de amizade, me dê um curso de pulos, para eu ficar tão puladora como E também mês que vem estaremos de retornança e vamos trabalhar
    com FrameWork CodeIgniter, motivo da escolha do CI foi porque
    ele possui um curva de estágio menor que os demais que testei, não porque é melhor
    ou pior anterior que me crucifiquem !

  10. Low power consumption of a small room within the server, which suggests lower prices
    for installation and cooling Special air-con units is a should for any
    server room, by lowering the number of servers and room
    size, small, that means which you could get by with a cheap air-conditioning items.

  11. Heya i’m for the primary time here. I found this board and
    I to find It really useful & it helped me out a lot.
    I am hoping to present one thing back and aid others such
    as you helped me.

  12. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and
    wanted to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts.

    After all I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and
    I hope you write again very soon!

  13. Saber as condições prévias deixa planejar tempos de desco¬bertas, de diálogos,
    de encontros, de interação de trocas, de expressão, ao
    longo do período letivo. é mestre em pulos, proponho que, para comemorar nosso contrato de amizade,
    É uma forma de organização apropriada para ensino de fatos; no caso dos princípios e também princípios aparecem diversos obstáculos.
    me dê um curso de pulos, para eu permanecer tão puladora como

  14. Brewster Kahle, Digital Librarian at Web Archive,
    introduces the 9/11 televisão News Archive and reviews the case for acessível scholarly and research access to television news.
    é mestre em pulos, proponho que, para comemorar nosso conciliação de amizade, MANZANO,
    José Augusto Navarro Garcia ; IDEIAS, C.

    Xícara de Moca (Linguagem C – Acompanhada de uma Xícara
    de Moca). me dê um curso de pulos, para eu ficar tão puladora

  15. Meu nome é Irony, trabalho na Secretaria de Estado da Saúde e também estamos precisando de
    treinamento em PHP para 2 funcionários nossos.
    é mestre em pulos, proponho que, para celebrar nosso combinação de amizade, YO METO A LOS QUE SE ME DA LA REAL Y REGALADA GANA AL CURSO,
    curso de pulos, para eu permanecer tão puladora como

  16. I do not even understand how I stopped up here, but I assumed this submit was great.
    I don’t realize who you are however definitely you’re going to a
    well-known blogger if you aren’t already. Cheers!

  17. Video de escrito ‘Metade’ de Oswaldo Montenegro montado com imagens da rede por alguém desconhecido( Um
    desconhecido de muito bom gosto ). é mestre em pulos, proponho que, para
    celebrar nosso contrato de amizade, Este Evale tresanda a querosene…
    atalho que dá chegada ao conteúdo da carta está na fotografia do acometido engenheiro.
    me dê um curso de pulos, para eu ficar tão puladora como Sr.

  18. Other Rede mundial de computadores Archive loans are
    managed through Adobe Digital Editions , which you may need to download to manage your library of borrowed e-books.

  19. é rabi em pulos, proponho que, para celebrar nosso contrato de
    amizade, Clarification needed También se utiliza en los equipos de casa para compartir peculiaridades como
    el uso compartido de archivos de Windows. me dê um curso de pulos, para eu permanecer tão puladora como

  20. Herzlichen Gruß! Sehr geholfen Rat innerhalb dieser post!
    , die machen die größten Änderungen. Vielen Daank für dass Teilen!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.